Vitamin D deficiency is a problem for both vegans and omnivores alike.
Recent research shows that around 77% of Americans are vitamin D deficient, particularly in the winter.
If you’re in Canada like I am, or even more north, your risk is likely even higher.
Vegans face an even greater challenge because the only good food sources of vitamin D are animal products.
Technically some mushrooms have vitamin D, but their form isn’t absorbed well.
So if you aren’t spending a lot of time in the sun during summer to fill up your vitamin D stores, a supplement will help you feel a lot better.
I wrote this guide specifically to help vegans find the best vitamin D supplement for them.
What to Look for In a Vegan Vitamin D Supplement
I’ll try to keep this brief and simple.
There are 3 main things that you need to consider when looking for a vitamin D supplement:
- Type – Vitamin D2 vs D3
- Amount per serving
- Do you need Vitamin K as well?
Let’s go through each quickly.
Which Type of Vitamin D is Best? D2 or D3?
Vitamin D has several forms, but the 2 dominant ones that you’ll see in supplements are vitamin D2 and D3.
Vitamin D2 is found in mushrooms as far as food goes, and is the type often added to fortified foods.
Unfortunately, studies have shown that vitamin D3 is far more effective than D2 at raising the blood levels of the usable form – calcifediol.
Your skin produces vitamin D3 when you spend time in the sun. In contrast, vitamin D2 is produced by plants and mushrooms exposed to sunlight.
It’s somewhere on the order of twice as effective according to some studies.
So while D2 is better than nothing, there’s no reason not to look for a vegan version of D3. All the top products that I’ll go over later are vitamin D3.
How is Vegan Vitamin D3 Made?
You wouldn’t be the first to wonder where plant-based D3 came from if D3 is usually only found in animals.
It’s actually made from lichen(an algae-like plant), whereas non-vegan D3 is extracted from lanolin (sheep’s wool oil) typically.
How Much Vitamin D Should You Get in a Supplement?
There’s a lot of debate about this between medical professionals and in literature.
For a “high” dose, you’ll hear anything from 800 IU all the way up to 5,000 IU, per day.
Side note: IU means “International Unit”, which is based on the actual biological effect that a substance have. This let’s us compare the effectiveness of different forms of substances (like vitamin D) against each other.
If someone is severely deficient in vitamin D, they will often get supervised doses of up to 25,000 IU multiple times a week.
In one study of elderly people, 400 IU per day was not enough to prevent fractures, but 700-800 IU per day did reduce the chance of fractures. So that’s probably the minimum you want.
Like I said though, it’s controversial.
Many experts say that’s too low and that you need at least 1,000 IU per day if you’re getting no sun.
Many say up to 4,000-5,000 IU is needed to correct a deficiency.
One warning before moving on: Vitamin D is a fat-soluble vitamin, which means that you don’t necessarily just excrete the extra. It is possible to get too much and get sick.
Currently, the tolerable upper limit for someone who is healthy is 4,000 IU, according to the NIH.
It’s completely fine to get a supplement with 5,000 IU per serving, and just have 1 serving every other day (or split a capsule in half). Completely up to you.
Do You Need to Take Both Vitamin K and D3?
Finally, if you did any further research about vitamin D, you’ll notice that vitamin K is often mentioned.
Both the vitamins have functions related to each other, and there are concerns that very high doses of vitamin D may deplete vitamin K stores, leading to a vitamin K deficiency.
No conclusive research has proven this yet, but you should be aware of it.
If you want to be on the safe side, you should also take a vitamin K supplement alongside vitamin D.
Keep in mind that the concern is for high doses of vitamin D, so you could also be more conservative with your supplement’s dosage if you’re worried about this.
The 5 Best Vegan Vitamin D3 Supplements: By Dosage, Cost and Type
Now we can actually get to the most reputable and high quality vegan vitamin D3 products.
To get full effect from a vitamin D supplement, eat it alongside some sort of fat. It’s a fat-soluble vitamin, and will absorb much better than if you consume it alone.
Here’s a summary chart that will help you narrow down your prospects:
|Name||Vitamin D (IU)||Cost per serving||Type|
|Pure D3 + K2||5000||$$||Liquid drops|
|Garden of Life Multi (*for kids)||800||$$$||Gummies|
Now let’s go into each in a bit more detail.
Doctor’s Best is a very popular supplement manufacturer (both for vegans and non-vegans).
Their non-vegan D3 is extremely popular and highly rated.
This product is about as cheap as you’re going to get for a vegan vitamin D3 supplement.
There’s 2,500 IU per serving, which I find to be a nice amount personally. It’s well over that minimum recommended level, but not close to a potentially dangerous amount.
There is a tiny bit of maltodextrin and sucrose, but you won’t taste those much.
Just in case it’s confusing, “Pure” is the name of the company, it’s not like this product is any more pure than the rest here.
This is the only supplement here that is in liquid form.
Each drop gives you 1,000 IU, so you can easily choose whatever dose you want.
Unlike pretty much all others, it has vitamin K2 built-in as well. You get 136 mcg per drop, which is a tiny bit over 100% of the RDA for an adult male.
The drops also include coconut oil and olive oil, which provide the fats you need to absorb the vitamins effectively.
Overall this is my personal favorite of the ones on the list. It’s convenient, reasonably priced, and gives you everything you might need all in a few drops.
MRM makes a wide range of vegan supplements. I first tried one of theirs when I came across their vegan protein powder, and they make pretty high quality stuff.
This vitamin comes in a standard sized capsule, with 5,000 IU per serving. You might want to split it up into halves if you think that’s too much.
On top of the standard capsule ingredients like rice flour, there’s also maltodextrin and sucrose. Small amounts, but if those really bug you, try a different option.
RealDose’s D3 comes in mini capsules.
If you have trouble swallowing full sized ones, these are a good option.
It’s also one of the few capsules with no sugar at all.
Each capsule has 1,000 IU, which is perfect if you wanted to be on the safe side.
Best for Kids: Garden of Life Multi
There aren’t many options for children, but I came across this multivitamin that has 800 IU of vitamin D in it that’s made for kids.
Garden of Life is a very well-known vegan supplement maker, and most kids will love the taste of these.
That’s mostly due to the 5 grams of sugar per serving, but I assume that’s necessary to get kids to take a “vitamin” of any kind.
The cost is a bit high, but you won’t find many other options for children if you’re looking for them.