Does Vegan Cheese Melt? [Experiment Results]


Vegan cheese, also referred to as “Gary”, can be a strange thing if you’re not used to it.

The taste isn’t quite as good as “real” cheese still, but it’s come a long way in recent years.

Similarly, while vegan cheese even a few years ago melted really poorly, it’s improved.

To give a look at what to expect, I made a few vegan grilled cheese sandwiches with a few of the most popular vegan cheese slices: Chao (my personal favorite), and Earth Island.


I’m not a great cook or food photographer, but the sandwiches still turned out pretty good in my opinion. I’ll give you a close-up look at how well the cheese melted.

Test 1: Melting Chao Cheese Slices

Here’s the finished sandwich using a single slice of Chao. I wouldn’t recommend using more than 2 slices max per sandwiches, you definitely don’t want to overdo vegan cheeses in general.

vegan grilled cheese with chao

From that view (the bottom edge), you can see that the cheese slice is glistening a bit. It’s heated, but not excessively melted.

The more important view is how it looks inside, so here’s what the sandwich looks like when cut open.

chao grilled cheese inside view

You can click the picture to see a larger version if needed.

The Chao cheese is definitely melted.

Here’s another close-up of the inside:

chao vegan cheese melted inside

So while it is melted, it won’t have the typical “stringy” texture that dairy cheese has. It’s more clumpy and gooey.

That being said, the sandwich still tasted great, and fairly similar to how grilled cheese made with dairy tastes.

Test 2: Melting Earth Island Cheese Slices

I made this sandwich with an Earth Island “cheddar” slice right after the Chao sandwich.

I used the same process, but it’s clear that this one didn’t melt quite as well:

vegan earth island grilled cheese

But while the outside doesn’t look too great, the inside was definitely melted:

earth island grilled cheese inside view

I would say this one was even “gooier” than the Chao cheese, which isn’t a texture that most people are aiming for.

The taste was fine, definitely not bad, just not amazing.

Summary: Did The Vegan Cheese Slices Melt?

I did only test 2 brands of vegan slices, but they both did melt to a decent degree.

More importantly, they tasted good too.

There’s still a lot of room for improvement when it comes to vegan cheeses that melt, but I think they do a good job if you’re really craving something like a grilled cheese or have a good vegan grilling recipe to try out.

About the author

Dale Cudmore

Your friendly neighborhood vegan from Toronto. I've spent over 6 years as a freelance nutrition writer and researcher. During this time, I've tested over 50 vegan protein powders, and over 100 other types of vegan supplements.

Add comment