Palm oil – that stuff you find in tons of processed foods.
You get it by extracting oil from the palm fruit.
Certainly sounds vegan, right?
By the most common definition of veganism, palm oil is vegan. If you were looking for a simple answer, there it is.
However, many vegans do not eat palm oil, at all.
There’s 2 main issues:
- Human rights violations
- Animals killed to grow more palm (particularly orangutans and Sumatran tigers).
While neither of these are technically necessary to grow palm trees, they are common practice in the industry.
Palm oil might be the most grey area in the world of veganism.
I’ve been on both sides of this issue and have spent many hours reading about it before writing this post.
The conclusion I’ve come up with (spoilers) is that palm products are vegan. If I see someone eating something with palm in it, I’m not going to be thinking (“that guy/girl isn’t vegan, call the vegan police!”).
However, I still personally don’t eat palm whenever possible, because a lot of the same logic that causes people to go vegan in the first place also applies here.
I’ll break down this conclusion in the post as simply as possible, as this can all get overwhelming.
Human Rights Violations
People are animals.
As a vegan, it’s normal not to want other people to suffer, even if cows and pigs are the typical animals that come to mind when thinking about veganism.
In a report by the International Labor Rights Forum, they found several human rights violation after visiting 3 palm tree plantations in Indonesia (in South East Asia, where most palm oil comes from).
Two of them really stand out to me:
- Workers are misled into working for these plantations, and forced to stay and work because they get into a debt-bondage situation.
- Workers are forced to bring children to work to meet virtually impossible quotas. The kids are not directly employed by the plantation, so “technically” they’re off the hook.
To make this even worse, these were at Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) certified plantations. These are the “good” ones, which shows how bad the industry is.
Animals Killed To Grow More Palm
While it’s definitely possible to grow palm trees without hurting animals, that’s not the reality of the situation.
The demand is so big, and the profits are big enough that poorer countries are destroying important peat lands and forests at an incredible rate to create more plantations.
Sumatra is an Indonesian island, home to some of the most endangered animals and critical ecosystems. It’s also where a lot of deforestation occurs to create land for palm trees.
Forests are burned, and animals die in them directly.
There have been numerous stories and videos of orangutans being beat and massacred by workers, sometimes forced back into burning forests.
I’m not going to embed any pictures here because they are heartbreaking. But if you want/need proof, just Google “palm oil orangutans” and go to the images tab and you’ll see exactly what I’m talking about.
The Sumatran population of orangutan is endangered, with just a few thousand left alive.
Additionally, the Sumatran tiger population is in similar dire straits. They’ve lost the majority of their habitats, and there are an estimated 600 left.
Keep in mind that most palm oil comes from countries in South East Asia, with these sorts of conditions.
Palm oil’s growing and harvesting directly causes great amounts of animal suffering and death because of the practices followed.
But does this mean palm oil isn’t vegan?
This is the tricky part, because we have to consider the alternatives.
Veganism is typically about reducing animal suffering wherever reasonably possible.
But palm is efficient – It would take multiple times the amount of land to grow alternatives like coconut, corn, etc. Animals die when we clear land for that (are orangutans and tigers more important than them? I think most would say neither are more important than the other).
If companies that use palm oil switched to another oil, there might be even more animals killed.
And even if everyone boycotts palm, those poor South East Asian people will clear rainforest to plant dates or some other plants.
You have to ask yourself whether all this is a reasonable way to reduce animal suffering. Most would say it’s not reasonable, and that’s why palm oil is technically vegan.
Now you can still think supporting this industry is messed up and avoid palm yourself, I certainly do, but that goes beyond veganism in my eyes.
What About Sustainable Palm Oil?
I mentioned the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) earlier.
The RSPO was supposed to be the answer to unsustainable practices like the ones above.
Instead, it turned out to be another organization whoms words were not followed by actions.
Even after it was pointed out that their standards left loopholes, no issues were addressed.
That report I went over above happened many years after the RSPO was formed, and clearly unethical and unsustainable farms can still get certified by the organization.
Tim Killeen, a representative for Conservation International summed it up well:
The RSPO controls the market exporting to Europe, basically. China doesn’t care. India doesn’t care. Domestic consumption in Vietnam, Korea, they don’t care…Don’t expect the RSPO to stop the problems.
The coordinator from the Center for Orangutan Protection also added:
Forests are still cleared and orangutans are continually killed…All criteria on sustainable palm oil and certification process are merely public lies.
However, that was a few years ago.
And with that being said, RSPO certified sustainable palm oil is better than uncertified palm. They appear to be making slow progress, and people who have worked in the palm industry say while RSPO isn’t perfect, it’s significantly better than the alternative.
Rainforest Alliance is another specific certification body for sustainable palm products, and appears to be one of the better ones. Most other certification other than those 2 (they’re the biggest) typically don’t mean much and are just greenwashing.
So try to look for that at least if you’re conflicted about palm products.
Opinion: Palm Oil is Technically Vegan
Let me sum up where most vegans stand on this complicated mess:
- Palm is a plant product.
- The palm industry has terrible common practices in terms of animal cruelty and human rights.
- Animal are beaten, killed, and treated like absolute garbage in the way of a paycheck.
- But boycotting palm won’t reduce those unethical practices. Those poor (literally) workers see no other choice than to exploit the rainforest and its land for economic gain. They will simply continue to do it and grow a different plant (although for a bit less profit).
- RSPO or Rainforest Alliance certified sustainable palm oil is as “good” as you can get if you’re going to consume palm products, but they are far from a guarantee that ethical practices were used.
- Many ethical vegans avoid consuming palm products in order to not support the industry, but this goes beyond the scope of “reasonable” to most when it comes to the definition of veganism.
So to answer the original question of whether or not palm oil is vegan.
It’s nowhere close to as bad as animal products, but is still a industry with common unethical practices.
As a side note, the majority of palm is used for animal agriculture, so by going vegan in the first place, you’ve reduce the amount of palm produced on your behalf by a large amount.